Consortium fire insurance has been mandatory since 1948. However, being mandatory doesn't mean it's properly contracted. In our experience advising consortiums, we see the same mistakes repeated over and over: insured sums that aren't updated, expired fire extinguishers that invalidate the policy, coverage that doesn't include what the administrator thinks it includes. The result is always the same: when a claim occurs, the consortium discovers it won't collect what it expected, or simply won't collect at all. In this article, we review the seven most common mistakes and, most importantly, how to avoid them. If you're a property owner, board member, or administrator of a building, this information could save you millions of pesos.
1. Not updating the insured sum with inflation
This is the most costly and most frequent mistake. The fire insurance insured sum must reflect the total reconstruction value of the building's common areas at current values. With Argentina's inflation levels in recent years, a policy that isn't periodically updated can end up covering barely a fraction of the real cost. Imagine a building that contracted insurance with an insured sum of 50 million pesos two years ago. Today, reconstructing the same common areas could cost 150 million. If a partial fire damages 30% of common areas, the insurer will apply the proportionality clause: since the insured sum covers only one-third of the real value, they'll pay only one-third of the reported damage. The consortium expected to collect 45 million but receives 15. The recommendation is to review and adjust the insured sum at least twice a year, ideally at each renewal and mid-term.
2. Not having regulatory fire extinguishers
Many property owners are unaware of this requirement, but it's a condition for coverage to be valid: the building must have at least one ABC-type 5kg fire extinguisher every two floors. And it's not enough to just have them: they must be charged, with correct pressure, within their expiration date, accessible and properly signaled. If at the time of a claim the insurer verifies that extinguishers are expired, discharged, or simply don't exist, they have legal grounds to reject the claim totally or partially. It's one of the first elements the adjuster checks when inspecting the building after a fire. The cost of keeping extinguishers current is insignificant compared to the risk of losing coverage. Include extinguisher inspection and recharging in the annual expense budget and verify that the provider issues certificates for each service.
3. Confusing market value with reconstruction value
Fire insurance doesn't cover the building's market value or land value. It exclusively covers the reconstruction cost of common areas: structure, installations, elevators, boilers, plumbing, electrical installation, common area floors and finishes, roofs, facade. Market value includes location, square meter pricing in the area, and real estate supply and demand. None of that relates to how much it materially costs to reconstruct the building. In many cases, reconstruction value is less than market value (especially in premium areas). In others, it can be higher (older buildings with materials that are now more expensive or harder to find). The correct calculation should be done by a professional, ideally an appraiser or civil engineer, considering square meters of common areas, construction type, special installations (boilers, fire systems, elevators), and updated material and labor costs.
4. Not including common area contents
The basic fire policy covers the building structure, but many consortiums forget to insure common area contents. This includes lobby and hallway furniture, multipurpose room (SUM) equipment, maintenance tools and equipment, water pumps, tanks, pressurization systems, central climate control equipment, security cameras and access control systems, and doorman's area equipment. If a fire destroys the basement water pump system, the building's security cameras, and the lobby furniture, all of that goes uncovered if common area contents weren't specifically included in the policy. This item is added as additional coverage at a relatively low cost. Ask the administrator to verify whether the current policy includes it.
5. Not declaring building modifications or expansions
If the consortium made significant modifications in recent years (multipurpose room expansion, pool construction, terrace roofing, new elevator installation, lobby remodeling) and didn't declare them to the insurer, those improvements aren't covered. Additionally, if the modification altered the building's risk (for example, a barbecue grill area on the terrace) and wasn't reported, the insurer could argue there was an undeclared risk aggravation and reduce or reject payment for any claim, not just those related to the modification. The rule is simple: every time the building is modified, common areas are renovated, or new installations are added, the insurer must be informed to adjust the insured sum and policy conditions.
6. Auto-renewing without comparing options
Many consortiums renew insurance year after year with the same insurer and same conditions, without comparing market options. This is a mistake for several reasons: market conditions change, and what was the best option three years ago may not be today. New insurers enter the consortium segment with competitive proposals. Coverage packages are updated and may include additional services at no cost (emergency plumbing, locksmith, electrician). Furthermore, by not comparing, you lose the ability to negotiate: presenting an alternative quote to your current insurer is the most effective way to obtain better conditions or lower premiums. It's not necessarily about changing companies, but about knowing what the market offers to make an informed decision. An Insurance Advisor can perform this comparison for you and present the best available options.
7. Not reading policy exclusions
All policies have exclusions: specific situations in which the insurer doesn't pay. The most common exclusions in consortium fire insurance include: intentional fires caused by the insured, damage from provable lack of maintenance, fires in areas not declared in the policy, claims occurring during construction without insurer authorization, and damage from natural phenomena not included in basic coverage (flooding, earthquake). The most dangerous exclusion is lack of maintenance. If a fire originates from faulty electrical installation that should have been repaired, the insurer can argue negligence and significantly reduce payment or reject it completely. It's essential that the administrator carefully read the policy exclusions and communicate them to the board, so the consortium takes necessary measures to avoid falling into any of them.
Conclusion
The consortium's fire insurance is not a bureaucratic procedure that gets mechanically renewed every year. It's the fundamental protection of all property owners' assets. Each of these seven mistakes can mean the difference between fully recovering the damage or having to face an extraordinary expense of millions of pesos. The good news is that correcting them is straightforward and generally doesn't involve a significant premium increase. An Insurance Advisor can audit your consortium's current policy and detect these problems before it's too late. Because the best time to review your fire insurance is always before the fire.
Is your building's fire insurance properly set up?
We review your current policy at no cost and tell you whether the insured sum is enough. Insurance advisors since 1922.
Have my policy reviewed