You asked for two home insurance quotes, the numbers came back similar, and now you have to choose. The natural reaction is to take the cheaper one, or to stay with the better known insurer. Neither is an informed decision, because the price of a home policy is the consequence of a handful of technical definitions that never appear in the headline figure. Compare those definitions instead of the totals and within ten minutes you will see that two similar quotes can be very different products, and that sometimes the difference favours the cheaper one.
1. The deductible, or how much you put in before the policy responds
The deductible is the amount you carry on every claim. It is the strongest and quietest lever on price: two policies with identical covers and different deductibles can sit some way apart on the instalment. There is no good or bad deductible in the abstract, only one that fits your case. If it is so high that no small loss will ever exceed it, you are paying for cover that in practice only responds to serious events. If it is very low, you are financing minor claims you could absorb yourself. What does not work is not knowing which one you were given, and on most quotes that figure is there but goes unread.
2. First loss basis or average: the clause that decides what you collect
This is the technical difference that generates the most disputes after a loss and the one least often explained at quoting stage. Under average, if your sum insured fell short of the real value of the property, the settlement is reduced in the same proportion: insured for half of what you should have been, you collect half the loss even when the loss is below the sum insured. On a first loss basis, by contrast, the loss is paid up to the limit without that reduction. Two quotes with the same contents sum and different bases are not comparable: one is selling you a number, the other is selling you that number minus the underinsurance penalty.
3. The maximum limit per individual item
Inside contents cover there is almost always a cap per individual item. You can hold a generous contents sum and still collect a fraction for the laptop you work on, the bicycle or the jewellery, because each exceeds that per item limit. It is the figure that most quickly separates a quote built for your case from one assembled by default. When comparing, find that number on both and test it against the three or four most expensive objects in your home. If the cap falls short, the gap is closed by declaring those items separately, which almost always costs less than raising the overall sum.
4. Which covers are included and which are set at the minimum
Two policies can list the same covers and carry completely different limits on each one. Water damage, electrical damage to appliances, broken glass, cash machine theft, third party liability: all of them usually appear on the list, but with sublimits ranging from symbolic to reasonable. Liability is the most sensitive case, because it is the only cover whose potential loss bears no relation to the value of your home: a third party claim can far exceed the value of everything you own. Comparing a list of covers without reading the sublimits is comparing headings, not products.
5. The conditions you must meet for the policy to pay
Every policy imposes obligations on the insured, and some are more demanding than others. Minimum security measures for theft cover to respond, deadlines to report a loss, a ban on repairs before inspection, maintenance requirements for installations. These conditions neither raise nor lower the premium, but they define your real probability of collecting. A policy with requirements you cannot meet is an expensive policy at any price. This is the point where having an adviser read it to you beforehand beats a form that has you accept it with a click.
6. How to structure the comparison in ten minutes
Build a five row table from the points above and fill it in for each quote: deductible, settlement basis, per item limit, sublimits on the key covers, and required conditions. Only once that table is complete should you look at the price. You will find one of three things: that the more expensive quote buys something concrete and is worth the difference, that the two are equivalent and the cheaper one wins, or that the cheaper one is cheaper because it is missing something you need. All three conclusions are useful, and none of them can be reached by looking at the total alone.
Conclusion
Comparing home insurance on the final price is the fastest route to a bad decision, in either direction. With five figures on the table the comparison becomes objective, and the result is usually surprising: the real gap between full cover and trimmed cover tends to be much narrower than it looks. At Ayling Seguros we build the comparison with you, definitions in plain view, so the decision is yours and it is grounded.
Frequently asked questions
What is the deductible on a home policy?
It is the amount the insured carries on each claim. A higher deductible lowers the premium but leaves smaller losses effectively uncovered, so it should be chosen according to the kind of events you actually want covered.
What does first loss basis mean?
It means the loss is indemnified up to the sum insured without applying the proportional reduction for underinsurance. Under average, by contrast, if the declared sum fell short the settlement is cut in that same proportion.
Why is my laptop not covered by the full contents sum?
Because contents cover normally carries a maximum limit per individual item. Belongings above that cap are best declared separately when taking out the policy, with description and value.
Does the price matter more than each cover's sublimit?
The sublimit defines how much you will collect, so it determines the real value of what you are buying. Comparing prices between policies with very different sublimits means comparing different products.
What happens if I do not meet the required security measures?
The insurer may decline or reduce the settlement on the affected cover, typically theft. That is why those conditions are worth reviewing before buying, to confirm they are workable in your home.
Want a quote with the definitions in plain view?
Get your family home quote online and review deductibles, limits and covers before deciding.
Get a home insurance quote